Comments on: Reluctance towards indigenous language (In context to Jharkhand)

By: badal mahato

badal mahato — Fri, 14 Jan 2011 06:07:12 +0000

muslim vote bank politics of jharkhand goverment .
why urdu is second official language of jharkhand.
does urdu linked with jharkhandi culture?
SANTHALI AND BENGALI , 2ND OFFICIAL LANG OF JHARKH
why urdu is the second official language of jharkhand why not bengali.
urdu as second official language in indian states-
1. delhi 2. andhra pradesh 3. U.P 4. bihar 5. karnataka 6. jharkhand
urdu as first official language – jammu &kashmir
because of muslim vote bank politics muslims achieve from govt. what they want.
bengali language is like a mother not biased on cast community and religion.
Bangladesh is a muslim country with 90% muslim population but their mother tongue and official language is bengali.
bengali language in jharkhand-
east and west singhbhum ,saraikela kharsawan, silli tamar bundu of ranchi, chas chandankyari of bokaro disst,dhanbad,jamtara,dumka,pakur.
two types of banglabhashi population-
type1. pure bengali speaker migrants setteler from west bengal but they are seteled in jharkhand at least 300 years.
2. jharkhandi moolnivashi sadan banglabhashi. they speak mix or remix bangla with local language.
a. kurmali+bangla- silli tamar,
b. bangla+khortha
c.bangla+panchpargania
in year 2002 arjun munda govt. declare bangali and santhali as second official language of jharkhand but when madhu koda come in power he change the deceason and give urdu as second official language.
my sadan(mahato) friends ask me why bengali why not kurmali or khortha ?
Reason- jharkhandi languages like kurmali ,khortha,panchpargania are not developed language. these jharkhandi languages has following limitation -
1. lack of vocavoulari(sabd bhandar ki kami)
2. lack of scientific words and technical termology.
3. not have own scipt.
4. not well developed grammer
5.very limited word stock.
6. standandarisation of language- for example we speak hindi that is hindi of western U.P that is considerd as national language.
7. lack of written literature.
8. very much undeveloped language.
among the indian language sanskrit and Tamil is most developed language.
give santhali and bengali as second official language status

By: B. MURMU

B. MURMU — Tue, 28 Sep 2010 18:50:03 +0000

I KNOW WHEN JHARKHAND STATE GOVT. DECLARE THAT OFFICIAL LANGUAGE AS URDHU IN THIS PERIOD JHARKHAND PEOPLE’S NOT OBJECTION ON GOVT DESISION…AFTER DECISION DATE IN KORANDIHI CHALK TOTAL 8 PEOPLE’S ARRENGE THE STRIKE..IN THIS SITUATION WHERE SIDE JHARKHAND PEOPLE GONE ?

By: VALENTINE SINDURIA

VALENTINE SINDURIA — Fri, 20 Aug 2010 12:42:21 +0000

Dear Jyoti,
I liked your article. It encouages me to cultivate respect and reverence towards our mother tongue ( Santhali, Mundari, Oraon, kharia, Ho…….).In real sense, I feel our existence purely and totally relies on our mother tongue.But, unfortunately we do not realise this.As a student of St.Xaviers College Ahmedabad, Gujrat,I feel encouraged to see my fellow students speaking in their mother tongue.So let do something to preserve our mother tongue.Let us encourage our people to communicate in our on tongue. let us teach our younger generation about the inportance of our mother tongue.Otherwise our tribal identity will be ruined.

By: BADAL MAHATO

BADAL MAHATO — Thu, 01 Apr 2010 06:56:11 +0000

johar,
why urdu is official language of jharkhand why not bengali and santhali. there are thousands of govt. urdu schools in jharkhand. govt. aided financiaL GRANTED MINORITY URDU SCHOOL. MADARSHA BOARD COUNCIL,SPECIAL RECRUITMENT OF URDU TEACHERS. SHIBU SOREN GOVT. MUSLIM VOTE BANK POPLITICS. i am from east singhbhum district patamda . there are 33% population of jharkhand is banglabhashi then why urdu is second official language of jharkhand.